A 404 Not Found error means the server could not find the requested resource (URL). While fixing 404s won’t instantly boost rankings, ignoring them leads to poor user experience, wasted crawl budget, and lost link equity (PageRank). Fixing them is a critical part of maintaining an optimal website health score.
Step 1: Locating and Identifying 404 Errors
Before fixing, you must know where the errors are originating from.
Tool | Focus/Report Name | Why It’s Optimal |
Google Search Console (GSC) | Index > Pages > “Not found (404)” | Primary source. These are the specific 404s that Googlebot has encountered and deems important. |
Site Audit Tools | Internal Links Report | Identifies broken links within your own website that point to missing pages. |
Backlink Tools | Broken Backlinks Report | Shows external websites linking to your missing 404 pages (lost link equity). |
Step 2: Optimal Strategies for Fixing 404 Errors
The fix you choose depends on the page’s original purpose and whether the content still exists. UTDS Optimal Choice recommends against simply leaving 404s, especially if they are highly linked.
Scenario | Optimal Fix Strategy | HTTP Status Code |
Page Deleted/Moved Permanently | 301 Redirect: The most common fix. Redirect the old, non-existent URL to the most relevant, current, and related page on your site. | 301 Moved Permanently |
Page Temporarily Unavailable | 302 Redirect: Use only if the page will return in its exact same form shortly (e.g., maintenance). Avoid if possible, as 301 is usually superior. | 302 Found (Temporary) |
Page Deleted, No Relevant Replacement | 410 Gone: Use this instead of 404 for pages you have permanently and deliberately removed. Google is often faster at de-indexing a 410 page than a 404. | 410 Gone |
Broken Internal Link (Typo) | Correct the Source Link: The 404 URL is valid, but the link pointing to it has a typo. Fix the internal link’s HTML/CMS entry. | N/A (Fix is on the internal linking page) |
Tip: Never redirect every 404 to your homepage. This is called a “soft 404” pattern and creates a poor user experience. Always redirect to the most topically relevant page.
Step 3: Improving the User Experience for True 404s
Sometimes, 404 errors are inevitable (e.g., a user mistypes the URL). In these cases, your custom 404 page is your last chance to retain the visitor.
Component | Optimal UX Implementation | Why it Works |
Clear Message | Clearly state: “Oops! We can’t find that page,” using UTDS Optimal Choice branding and tone. | Reduces frustration and manages user expectation immediately. |
Search Bar | Include a highly visible and functional internal search bar. | Allows users to immediately search for the content they intended to find. |
Key Links/CTAs | Link directly to high-value pages: Homepage, Services, Contact, or your top Knowledge Base topics. | Guides the user back into the site’s main conversion funnels. |
Sitemap Link | A link to the HTML sitemap for complex sites. | Provides an index of your content for users who are digging deeper. |
Salesforce
